Protector: Home Network Defense
After securing the individual user, the next layer of defense involves fortifying the entire home network. A typical consumer-grade router is a black box with limited functionality, infrequent security updates, and poor visibility into network traffic. For a Protector running a home lab, this is an unacceptable risk. Treating the home network as a micro-enterprise, with a dedicated, powerful, and transparent security gateway, is essential. This layer focuses on the tools needed to control traffic, sanitize data streams, and provide secure remote access to the lab.
The Gateway Guardian: Open-Source Firewalls
The cornerstone of any secure network is a powerful, configurable firewall. Instead of relying on consumer hardware, a Protector can repurpose an old PC or purchase a dedicated low-power appliance to run a FOSS firewall distribution. These FreeBSD-based platforms provide enterprise-grade features, complete control over network traffic, and a level of transparency that is impossible with commercial routers.
OPNsense: In 2025, OPNsense stands as the recommended choice for most home lab users. Forked from pfSense in 2014, it has distinguished itself with a modern, intuitive web interface, a predictable and frequent update schedule (major releases twice a year, patches bi-weekly), and a strong commitment to its open-source principles. Its vibrant community and extensive plugin library make it both powerful and accessible for users moving beyond basic networking.
pfSense: As the long-standing incumbent, pfSense has a well-earned reputation for stability and raw performance. It is widely used in both home and enterprise environments. However, its development, led by the commercial entity Netgate, has moved towards a less open model with the introduction of pfSense Plus, a closed-source version that receives features and security updates ahead of the free Community Edition. This, combined with past community controversies, has led many in the FOSS community to favor OPNsense's more transparent and community-driven approach.
A key capability unlocked by these powerful firewalls is network segmentation using Virtual LANs (VLANs). This is the practice of creating logically separate networks on the same physical hardware. For a home lab, this is a critical security measure. For instance, a user can create:
A Trusted LAN for servers, personal computers, and other secure devices.
An IoT VLAN for untrusted or less secure devices like smart TVs, security cameras, and smart home gadgets.
A Guest VLAN for visitors, providing internet access but no access to internal network resources.
By implementing strict firewall rules between these VLANs (e.g., allowing the Trusted LAN to initiate connections to the IoT VLAN, but blocking the reverse), the "blast radius" of a compromise is significantly contained. A hacked smart lightbulb on the IoT VLAN cannot attack the file server on the Trusted LAN.
The Gateway Guardian: Open-Source Firewalls - Resource Table
This table is dynamically updated. View full-screen version
Sanitizing the Stream: Network-Wide DNS Filtering
A significant portion of malware, advertising, and user tracking is delivered via the Domain Name System (DNS). While browser-based ad blockers are effective, they are an incomplete solution, offering no protection for other applications or devices like smart TVs. A far more comprehensive approach is DNS sinkholing, which intercepts all DNS queries on a network and blocks requests for known malicious, tracking, or ad-serving domains before a connection is ever made. This not only enhances privacy and security for every device on the network but also improves performance by preventing unwanted content from being downloaded.
Cloud-Based DNS Protection Services
For many users, cloud-based DNS protection services offer the easiest and most comprehensive protection. These services require no hardware setup and can be configured network-wide at the router level or per-device. They often provide more advanced threat intelligence and faster updates than self-hosted solutions.
NextDNS: A modern, highly configurable DNS service that acts as a "firewall for the internet." NextDNS provides comprehensive protection against malware, tracking, and ads while offering granular control over what gets blocked. Its standout features include detailed analytics showing what's being blocked, custom blocklists, parental controls, and the ability to configure different policies for different devices or networks. It supports modern encrypted DNS protocols (DoH, DoT) and can be easily configured on any device or router. The free tier provides 300,000 queries per month, which is sufficient for most home users.
Quad9: A free, privacy-focused DNS service operated by a Swiss non-profit organization. Quad9 automatically blocks access to malicious domains based on threat intelligence from multiple commercial and open-source feeds. Unlike many DNS services, Quad9 does not log personal data and has undergone independent privacy audits. It provides a good balance of security and privacy for users who want "set it and forget it" protection without the granular control offered by NextDNS.
Cloudflare for Families: Cloudflare's family-friendly DNS service offers two tiers: one that blocks malware and phishing (1.1.1.2) and another that also blocks adult content (1.1.1.3). While not as feature-rich as NextDNS, it's completely free, extremely fast due to Cloudflare's global network, and provides basic protection with zero configuration.
Self-Hosted DNS Filtering
For users who prefer complete control over their DNS filtering and want to keep all DNS queries within their network, self-hosted solutions remain valuable. These tools can be combined with upstream encrypted DNS services for enhanced privacy.
Pi-hole: The classic and widely beloved DNS sinkhole solution, Pi-hole is famous for its ability to run on low-power hardware like a Raspberry Pi. It is straightforward to set up, has a massive community providing extensive blocklists and support, and offers a functional web interface for monitoring network activity. While it does not support modern encrypted DNS protocols out of the box, it can be paired with a recursive DNS resolver like Unbound to enhance privacy further. Pi-hole is ideal for users who want to learn about DNS filtering and enjoy tinkering with their setup.
AdGuard Home: A powerful and modern alternative to Pi-hole, AdGuard Home offers a more polished user interface and several advanced features built-in. Its most significant advantage is native support for encrypted DNS protocols, including DNS-over-HTTPS (DoH), DNS-over-TLS (DoT), and DNS-over-QUIC (DoQ). This encrypts DNS queries between the home lab and the upstream resolver, preventing the ISP from snooping on browsing habits. It also includes built-in parental control features and uses a filtering rule syntax that allows for more complex blocking rules.
Recommended Approach
For most Protectors, the optimal strategy is a hybrid approach: NextDNS as the primary solution for its ease of setup, comprehensive features, and excellent mobile device support, with Pi-hole or AdGuard Home as a backup for learning and additional control. This provides redundancy and allows for experimentation without disrupting daily internet usage.
Recommended Approach - Resource Table
This table is dynamically updated. View full-screen version
The Private Tunnel: VPN Solutions for Every Need
A Virtual Private Network (VPN) creates a secure, encrypted tunnel over an untrusted network, like public Wi-Fi. For the Protector, VPN solutions fall into two categories: self-hosted VPNs for accessing your home lab remotely, and commercial VPN services for general privacy protection and accessing geo-restricted content.
Self-Hosted VPNs: Secure Access to Your Home Lab
Self-hosting a VPN server within the home lab offers several benefits: absolute control over logs and data, a static and dedicated IP address that is not shared with others, and secure, encrypted access to all internal lab services from anywhere in the world.
WireGuard: The modern standard for VPNs, WireGuard is lauded for its simplicity, performance, and state-of-the-art cryptography. It has a dramatically smaller codebase than older protocols, making it easier to audit and less prone to vulnerabilities. Configuration is as simple as exchanging public keys, similar to SSH, making it exceptionally easy for beginners to set up, especially with the help of helper scripts and tools like WireGuard Easy. Its high speed and low overhead make it ideal for everything from remote server administration to streaming media from a home server. Its main limitation is that it uses UDP, which can sometimes be blocked on restrictive corporate or public networks.
OpenVPN: The battle-tested veteran of the VPN world, OpenVPN's greatest strength is its flexibility. It can be configured to run over the TCP protocol on port 443, making its traffic indistinguishable from standard HTTPS web traffic. This allows it to bypass even the most restrictive firewalls that block other VPN protocols. This flexibility comes at the cost of significantly more complex setup - requiring the management of a full Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) with certificate authorities - and lower performance compared to WireGuard.
Commercial VPN Providers: Privacy and Anonymity
While self-hosted VPNs are excellent for accessing your home lab, they don't provide anonymity or help with geo-restricted content. For these use cases, reputable commercial VPN providers offer independently audited, privacy-focused services. The key criteria for evaluating VPN providers include: no-logs policies that have been independently audited, strong encryption protocols, a large server network, and a business model based on subscriptions rather than data monetization.
Top Tier Privacy-Focused Providers:
Mullvad: Widely regarded as the gold standard for privacy-focused VPNs. Based in Sweden, Mullvad operates on a unique philosophy: they don't want to know who you are. Account registration requires no personal information - not even an email address. You're assigned a random account number, and payment can be made with cryptocurrency or even cash sent by mail. They maintain a verified no-logs policy, undergo regular independent security audits, and their entire client software is open-source. The service operates on a flat €5/month pricing model with no long-term contracts or discounts, reflecting their principled approach to privacy.
IVPN: Another privacy-first provider that takes a similar approach to Mullvad. Based in Gibraltar, IVPN requires minimal personal information for registration, accepts anonymous payments including cryptocurrency, and maintains independently audited no-logs policies. They offer advanced features like multi-hop connections (routing traffic through multiple servers) and have undergone comprehensive security audits. IVPN is also committed to transparency, regularly publishing detailed transparency reports about any government requests they receive.
Proton VPN: Developed by the team behind ProtonMail, Proton VPN brings the same privacy-focused philosophy to VPN services. Based in Switzerland with strong data protection laws, Proton VPN offers a verified no-logs policy, strong encryption, and integration with the broader Proton ecosystem. They provide a generous free tier (with limitations) and paid plans with advanced features like Secure Core (multi-hop routing through privacy-friendly countries) and Tor over VPN support.
Solid Privacy-Conscious Options:
ExpressVPN: While more mainstream than the providers above, ExpressVPN has built a strong reputation for privacy and security. They maintain a verified no-logs policy that has been tested in real-world legal situations, offer strong encryption, and provide excellent performance with a large global server network. However, they're owned by Kape Technologies, which has a controversial history in the data collection space, making them less ideal for users with high privacy requirements.
VPN Selection Guidelines
For Maximum Privacy/Anonymity: Choose Mullvad or IVPN
For Integration with Secure Email: Consider Proton VPN if you're already using ProtonMail
For Streaming/General Use: ExpressVPN or Proton VPN offer good performance
For Home Lab Access: Self-host WireGuard or OpenVPN
The tools in this perimeter defense layer do not operate in isolation; they form a synergistic system. A properly configured home network will see the OPNsense firewall acting as the central router and DHCP server. This DHCP server will be configured to assign the IP address of NextDNS (or a local DNS filter) as the DNS resolver for all network clients. Finally, the WireGuard VPN server, also running in the lab, will be configured to route traffic through your protected DNS when remote clients connect. This creates a seamless security posture: a user on their laptop at a coffee shop can connect to their home VPN, and their traffic is not only securely tunneled but also filtered for ads and trackers by their chosen DNS protection, extending the protection of the home lab wherever they go.
VPN Selection Guidelines - Resource Table
This table is dynamically updated. View full-screen version
Everything on Shared Sapience is free and open to all. However, it takes a tremendous amount of time and effort to keep these resources and guides up to date and useful for everyone.
If enough of my amazing readers could help with just a few dollars a month, I could dedicate myself full-time to helping Seekers, Builders, and Protectors collaborate better with AI and work toward a better future.
Even if you can’t support financially, becoming a free subscriber is a huge help in advancing the mission of Shared Sapience.
If you’d like to help by becoming a free or paid subscriber, simply use the Subscribe/Upgrade button below, or send a one-time quick tip with Buy me a Coffee by clicking here. I’m deeply grateful for any support you can provide - thank you!